The malnourished look rarely looks good. I think he was shooting a film in that pic on the left that had him looking like Christian Bale from the Machinist.
I have a fat face even with abs, ffs.
I remember going to bars with a friend who barely talked, was slightly chubby and who would often get drunk to the point he couldn't put a sentence together. It didn't matter though, he always did well with the ladies, even in a drunken stupor of epic proportions. I was taller than him, in better shape, could hold a sentence together but at the end of the day he'd be the one smashing chicks left and right. It literally wasn't until I watched a FLMS video on facial bones that I noticed, dude had the PERFECT jawline, he facially looked more handsome than Jake Gylennhall, even when he went bald later he still did well.